Boys names that are old-fashioned but not too stuffy or rare?

We both want a name that's traditional rather than modern/trendy, but we are having trouble agreeing beyond that. I love names that sound antique and aren't too common (Harlan, Eldon, Rohan, Ainsley) while my husband thinks those kind of sound made-up since you don't meet many of them these days. He'd prefer a more standard old-fashioned name (like Abraham, which I think is too stuffy). Any suggestions on names we might both like that are traditional, old-fashioned, and mature sounding but can still be seen as youthful? (For example, we both like Everett, Gideon, Oliver, and Harrison.) Bonus if the name sounds woodsy!